Ken Rockwell Pwnd
Michael Reichmann of The Luminous Landscape recently read one of Ken Rockwell’s masterpieces and wrote the rebuttal most of us have wanted to write ever since having the unfortunate coincidence of coming across Rockwell’s site. In the brilliant, “Your Camera Does Matter“, Reichmann writes,
Discussing the merits of one tool over another is relevant. Some lenses, cameras and other photographic tools are better than others. In some cases they are objectively better, while in others their degree of betterness will be subjetive and will depend on the specific needs of a particular photographer.
Um, Rockwell writes camera and lens reviews, albeit not very good ones, but he writes them. It seems contradictory to then write an essay arguing, in Ken Rockwellian style, that your camera doesn’t matter.
Compare this with Reichmann’s sage advice,
When a person asks these type of questions let’s be generous instead of snarky. Let’s ask them the type of photography that are doing, or plan on doing, and then if we have anything worthwhile to contribute, do so. But to spout holier-than-thou cliches one more time is simply the sign of either a lazy or an angry mind.
In an update to his essay Reichmann writes of Rockwell,
Unfortunately, from what I have seen of his writing in the referred to essay, as well as the rest of those on his site, consistency of thought and clarity of expression are not hallmarks of his writing style.
I have to agree that Rockwell is not a gifted writer (not to imply that I am). While it’s easy to say “just ignore his site if you don’t like it”, the fact of the matter is that a newbie photographer wouldn’t necessarily know that Rockwell’s advice is crap, even if he/she Google searched, if people like Michael didn’t write rebuttals. I think Michael has performed an important public server for newbies. And for my own sense of humor I say thank you, Michael.